Property owners liability insurance in Finland – slips, falls and falling snow
Property owners liability insurance (kiinteistön vastuuvakuutus) pays for injuries and damage your building or land causes to other people, when you as the owner are legally liable for them. In Finland it is usually part of the property insurance of a housing company or a property company, and in our experience the most common claims under it are injuries caused by unsafe paths and premises, slips on ice in winter and falls over potholes or obstacles in summer.
Finnish case law puts a heightened duty of care on property owners. After a slip, the owner has to show that the yard was maintained properly, so the outcome usually depends on what the maintenance log shows.
- Advice from an insurance lawyer on the Finnish property owners liability wordings
- Help when the insurer refuses a slip, falling snow or tenant claim
- Review of how your maintenance contract and your policies divide the risk
What property owners liability cover pays for
Property owners liability cover pays for bodily injury and damage to property that you cause to other people as the owner of the insured property, when you are liable for it under Finnish law. It also pays to find out whether you are liable at all.
The typical claims are a visitor who slips in the yard or trips over a pothole or an obstacle on a path, snow or ice falling on a car, a loose piece of the facade hitting a passer-by and water from your building damaging the neighbour’s property. The person who suffered the damage claims compensation from the owner. The owner then passes the claim to the insurer.
The insurer pays only if the owner is liable. In Finland liability usually requires negligence, meaning a mistake, carelessness or a failure to act. An accident on your property does not make you liable on its own. The policy does not pay compensation just because someone was hurt.
That is why the investigation is half of the cover. The insurer:
- finds out whether you are liable and how much compensation the law requires
- negotiates with the person making the claim
- handles or pays for the court case if the claim goes to court
If the insurer finds that you are not liable, it refuses the claim and defends that decision. Do not pay the claim yourself or accept it before the insurer has looked at it. Under all five wordings compared below, your own payment or acceptance does not bind the insurer unless the amount and the basis are obviously correct.
The insurer usually pays the investigation and defence costs on top of the compensation, but they can use up the limit of indemnity. Most of the wordings compared below count these costs into the limit.
Part of the property insurance in Finland
In Finland property owners liability insurance is usually bought as part of the property insurance (kiinteistövakuutus) of a housing company, a property company or another owner of a building. The same package often contains property management liability insurance (kiinteistön hallinnon vastuuvakuutus), which is a different cover.
Property owners liability insurance covers injury and property damage caused by the building and its land. Property management liability insurance covers pure financial loss caused by the board members or the property manager in managing the company, for example a wrong figure in a manager’s certificate that misleads an apartment buyer.
The premium is usually based on the volume of the buildings. Fennia, for example, prices the cover by building volume and can reduce a claim if the volume was given too low.
Rent lost while a damaged building is repaired is not a liability claim. It belongs to business interruption insurance in Finland, which in some wordings can include the owner’s rental income.
Slips and falls – the owner must prove the maintenance was adequate
After a slip on a Finnish property, the owner has to prove that ice and snow were dealt with properly. The person who fell does not have to prove that the owner was careless.
Finnish case law has long treated property owners as having a heightened duty of care for people moving on their property. In winter this means clearing snow from paths and gritting them as needed. When someone is injured in a fall, the owner avoids liability only by showing that the maintenance was adequate in the conditions, that the fall was caused by something other than the slippery surface, or that the weather made gritting impossible.
The liability is heightened but not strict. A property can be maintained properly and still be slippery in places, and a fall on a well-maintained yard does not make the owner liable.
What decides the case is evidence. The Insurance Complaints Board (FINE) expects the owner to present a reliable account from whoever handles the maintenance, such as a maintenance log, and compares it with weather data from the Finnish Meteorological Institute. A log that also records inspection visits is stronger evidence than one that shows only the days when grit was spread, because in FINE-047602 the Board noted that nothing showed how the yard was monitored between gritting rounds.
The weather before the fall matters as much as the day itself. During continuous heavy snowfall the owner does not have to grit, but the owner must have dealt with the ice before the snow started.
In FINE-047602 the last gritting had been done eleven days before the fall. The owner had no record of checking the yard in between. The insurer argued that it had been snowing, but the Board found the owner liable because nothing showed how the yard had been maintained before the snowfall.
A customer slipped on an icy bump at a busy pedestrian corner outside a shopping centre, about two hours after the yard had been gritted. The grit had run off the bump. Compensation was claimed from the property owner’s liability insurance. The dispute was whether gritting alone was adequate maintenance.
A maintenance log and weather data can also show that the owner was not liable.
A customer slipped in the yard of an insured property at 17.35. The maintenance company’s report showed snow clearing at 6.40 and gritting at 9.20 that day. Very light snow had fallen from about 13.00. Compensation was claimed from the property owner’s liability insurance. The dispute was whether the owner had shown adequate maintenance.
In our experience the most common mistake is made long before anyone falls. Especially in winter, property owners have not always required the maintenance company to keep an adequate gritting and maintenance log. Because the burden of proof is on the owner, a missing log often means that the owner cannot show it maintained the yard properly, and the owner has to pay compensation for the injury.
Make the log a written requirement in the maintenance contract. When you receive a claim after a fall, ask the maintenance company for its log for the days before the fall at once, and save the weather data for the same period.
Snow and ice falling from the roof
A property owner in Finland must make sure that snow and ice falling from the building do not endanger people or property, so damage from a roof is covered when the owner neglected that duty.
This duty comes from the Public Order Act (järjestyslaki). According to the Board, the owner’s primary duty is to remove the danger by clearing the roof. The other measure is cordoning off the danger area below.
The owner is expected to follow the weather. In one decision (VKL 430/04) snow had fallen for several days before the temperature rose above zero and snow slid off a metal roof onto a parked car. The Board found the danger foreseeable and the owner liable, because nobody had even claimed that parking under the roof could not have been prevented.
A block of ice falling from the roof of housing company P killed a person. Compensation was claimed from the housing company’s property owners liability insurance. The dispute was whether the company had neglected to clear the roof or to cordon off the danger area.
The dates of roof clearing, photos of the roof and the time the area was cordoned off were the evidence that showed the owner had not been negligent. Without such evidence the owner would have had difficulty showing that it acted carefully.
Owner, tenant or maintenance company – who is liable
The property owner remains liable to the injured person even when a maintenance company does the snow clearing and gritting. The claim therefore usually belongs to the owner’s liability insurance first.
Many Finnish property owners buy their maintenance from a maintenance company. The contract moves the work to the maintenance company but not the owner’s liability towards people who use the property.
In FINE-019024 snow had been dropped from a housing company’s roof onto the pavement. The maintenance company left the pavement without barriers while it fetched grit, and a pedestrian slipped. The insurer of the housing company refused, arguing that the fault was the maintenance company’s. Nobody disputed that the maintenance company had been careless, so the question was whether the owner was liable for it. The Board found that the owner is liable for the maintenance even when someone else carries it out, and recommended that the housing company’s insurer pay.
In our experience this is a very common misunderstanding. When an owner has bought winter maintenance from a maintenance company, it is often assumed that the company that did the gritting carelessly is liable for the fall. Under Finnish law the property owner is liable to the injured person.
The owner’s insurer can then try to recover the money from the maintenance company, but recovery can fail. A maintenance company’s general liability insurance usually does not cover liability that rests only on the maintenance contract, and the owner has to show that the maintenance company actually broke the contract.
In the follow-up decision on the same fall (FINE-029391), the housing company’s insurer could not recover the compensation. The Board found that it had not been shown that the maintenance company made the pavement slippery, and that the contract required it only to supplement the city’s gritting when needed, not to put up barriers.
What the contract says about snow clearing, gritting, roof clearing and cordoning off decides how much of the risk stays with the owner.
Make sure that the contract covers all the owner’s duties under the law. In a town plan area, for example, the owner of a plot usually also has to keep the pavement along the plot clear of snow and ice, unless the municipality has taken over the task.
Landlord general liability insurance
A landlord’s property owners liability insurance covers the landlord’s liability as the owner of the building, not the business the tenant runs in it. A tenant’s restaurant, shop or workshop needs its own general liability insurance (toiminnan vastuuvakuutus), which pays for damage the tenant’s business causes to customers and others.
LähiTapiola’s wording, for example, expressly excludes damage connected with business carried on in the building other than owning and managing the property.
The tenant’s financial losses are a separate question. When the building’s equipment breaks down, the tenant may claim lost sales or higher costs from the landlord. Those are pure financial losses, which property owners liability insurance does not cover.
In FINE-045196 the heat recovery unit of a commercial building broke down in March, and the repair was started only in late September. The tenant claimed about 8,300 euros of extra electricity costs, which the landlord paid. The Board found that the broken unit was the landlord’s own loss and the electricity costs were a pure financial loss, so the landlord’s insurance did not cover them.
Housing companies and their shareholders
A housing company’s property owners liability insurance also covers damage to its shareholders and their belongings, unless the shareholders have agreed to do the maintenance themselves.
A Finnish housing company (asunto-osakeyhtiö) owns the building. The shareholders own the shares that give them the right to use the apartments. For the liability insurance, a shareholder is another person. When snow from the roof damages a shareholder’s car, the company can be liable to the shareholder just as it would be to a visitor.
Two limits apply. Damage to the company’s own building is not damage to another person, so it belongs to the company’s property insurance. And if the shareholders have agreed to clear snow or grit the yard themselves, for example as voluntary work, the company is usually not liable to a shareholder who slips on the yard they agreed to look after.
Snow falling from the roof of housing company X damaged the shareholders’ property. Compensation was claimed from the housing company’s property owners liability insurance. The insurer argued that the damage was caused to the policyholder itself. The dispute was whether the shareholders had agreed to watch the snow on the roof themselves.
If your housing company relies on shareholders for some of the maintenance, write down who does what. An arrangement that nobody recorded is hard to prove later, both for the company and for the shareholder.
What property owners liability insurance does not cover
Property owners liability insurance does not cover damage to your own property or losses you are not legally liable for. The Finnish wordings typically exclude the following.
General liability insurance for real estate businesses
General liability insurance for a real estate business is needed on top of property owners liability insurance when the company does more than own buildings, for example maintenance with its own staff, construction or services for tenants.
Property owners liability insurance covers the liability that comes from owning the property. A real estate company whose own employees clear snow on other owners’ properties, renovate buildings or run a car park as a service has a business liability as well. That liability belongs to general liability insurance. See liability insurance in Finland for how the Finnish general liability policies work.
Three other covers are worth checking:
- property management liability insurance for the board of a housing company or a property company
- D&O insurance in Finland for the board and the managing director of a larger property company, when the property management cover is too narrow
- professional indemnity insurance for a property manager or a company that gives advice on real estate as a service
Five Finnish property owners liability policies compared
The five Finnish property owners liability policies cover the same basic liability but differ in property in your care, moisture damage and business carried on in the building.
Where the wordings differ
All five cover injury and property damage caused to others as the owner of the property, investigate the claim and exclude liability based only on a contract.
Breaking a safety instruction affects a liability claim less than a property claim. In liability insurance, ordinary carelessness does not reduce the compensation. Pohjantähti’s general terms, for example, allow the compensation to be reduced or refused only when the owner broke a safety instruction on purpose or through gross negligence, or when alcohol or drug use affected the failure.
An independent insurance broker in Finland can compare the limits and wordings of the Finnish insurers for your property.
Questions about property owners liability insurance in Finland
No law requires it, but the owner’s liability exists whether the property is insured or not. Leases usually require property insurance and only rarely liability insurance. When a whole building is leased, the lease requires the building to be insured, while a lease of premises requires property insurance for the leased premises. In practice a Finnish property insurance policy includes property owners liability cover by default alongside the cover for the building.
Both cover injury and property damage you cause to others, but property owners liability insurance covers only the liability that comes from owning the property. General liability insurance, also called public liability insurance, covers the liability of a business in its operations.
In Finland a limit of indemnity of 500,000 euros or one million euros has traditionally been considered enough for the liability cover in a property insurance policy. Recently, however, we have seen cases where a housing company’s liability exceeded even one million euros, because the injured person was young and the injury so serious that one million euros no longer covered the liability. We therefore recommend checking whether the limit should be raised to two million euros.
It covers the tenant as an injured person, for example when the tenant’s goods are damaged because the owner neglected the building. It does not cover the tenant’s own liability to customers, which belongs to the tenant’s general liability insurance.
Report the claim to your insurer and do not accept or pay it yourself. Ask the maintenance company for its log for the days before the fall, save the weather data for the same days and take photos of the place. The insurer decides on liability based on these.
Tell us about the claim against your property
Tell us what happened, who maintains the property and what the insurer has said. We will check whether the owner is liable, whether the claim belongs to your policy or the maintenance company’s, and what evidence the insurer needs. If the insurer has refused a claim you think it should pay, we help you challenge the decision.
Our fees: a single tender from 4,000 euros, ongoing broking from 5,000 euros a year. The fee is fixed and never a share of the premium. What the fee includes