Commercial legal expenses insurance in Finland – what business legal insurance covers
Commercial legal expenses insurance (yrityksen oikeusturvavakuutus) pays your company’s own lawyer and court costs when a dispute about your business goes to a Finnish district court or arbitration. It does not pay the amount in dispute. Nor does it pay for defending a damages claim that your liability insurance covers.
In our experience most refused legal expenses claims fail on timing rather than on the merits of the dispute. The dispute had not yet arisen when the lawyer started work, or the policy was less than two years old and the contract behind the dispute was older than the policy.
- A check of when your dispute arose and whether the two-year rule applies
- Help when the insurer refuses legal expenses cover or cuts the lawyer’s fees
- Advice on which policy pays your lawyer, legal expenses or liability
What commercial legal expenses insurance covers
Commercial legal expenses insurance covers the necessary and reasonable lawyer and court costs of the insured business in civil disputes, application matters and criminal cases where the company is the injured party. The case must be one that could go straight to a Finnish district court or arbitration.
Contract and commercial disputes
The most common use. A customer refuses to pay an invoice, a supplier delivers late or a subcontractor disputes the scope of the work. In each case the other side has denied your claim.
Employment disputes
A dispute with an employee about a dismissal or the terms of employment in the district court. None of the six Finnish wordings compared here excludes employment disputes, unlike many consumer policies.
Criminal cases where the company is the injured party
The company’s costs as the injured party, for example after embezzlement or fraud. The loss itself belongs to crime insurance. The company’s own criminal liability, such as a corporate fine, is excluded.
Court mediation, arbitration and insurance board cases
Your lawyer’s costs in court mediation and arbitration are covered. In the cases we have handled, the insurers have also paid for complaints to the Finnish insurance and consumer boards, even though most wordings do not mention them.
The cover pays what the dispute costs you, not what the dispute is about. If your company loses and has to pay the disputed invoice, the legal expenses insurance does not pay that invoice, even when it pays your lawyer in full. Your own working time, lost income and travel costs are also left out.
The district court requirement rules out a large group of cases. Matters heard by administrative and special courts, such as the administrative courts, the Market Court, the Labour Court and the Supreme Administrative Court, are excluded in the Finnish wordings. Tax disputes are therefore not covered, because they go to the administrative courts. A couple of wordings, LähiTapiola’s for example, make one exception and cover disputes about a trade name in the Market Court.
A dispute with your own insurer is covered like any other civil dispute. A refusal of an insurance claim is a denial of your claim, so a business that wants to challenge its property, liability or business interruption insurance decision can usually use its legal expenses insurance to pay the lawyer. In the cases we handle for companies, legal expenses insurance usually pays most of our fee after the deductible, which the company pays itself. The one dispute with your own insurer that the policy does not pay for is a dispute about the legal expenses cover itself.
Where the case may be heard is written in the policy schedule. Most Finnish wordings let the insurer agree on a territory wider than Finland. Disputes in the general courts or arbitration of that territory are then covered too. Pohjola’s wording, for example, covers only cases heard in Finland. If the territory is Finland, a dispute heard in another country can fall outside the cover entirely. We always recommend that a company with international customers checks the territory. Europe, for example, is a sensible minimum.
Does business insurance cover legal costs? Legal expenses vs liability insurance
Business insurance in Finland covers legal costs through two different policies. Legal expenses insurance pays your lawyer when your company claims something or has to defend itself in a dispute. General liability insurance pays the defence when someone claims damages from your company for injury or property damage it covers.
The line between the two policies is the most common source of confusion we see. When a customer claims that your work damaged its property, the claim belongs first to your general liability insurance in Finland. The liability insurer investigates whether your company is liable, negotiates with the claimant and handles or pays for the court case if the claim goes to court.
As a rule, the legal expenses wordings exclude costs that liability insurance pays or covers. Some wordings, Fennia’s for example, exclude them even when the liability insurance limit has run out, so the legal expenses cover does not pick up where the liability cover ends. The defence costs also use up the liability insurance limit instead of forming a separate budget on top of the compensation.
A damages claim against the company is still not automatically outside the legal expenses insurance. In case VKL 59/13 of the Insurance Complaints Board (FINE) a subcontractor’s employee was injured on a building site and claimed compensation from the main contractor A Oy, while A Oy’s former managing director was prosecuted for a work safety offence. The insurer refused legal expenses cover, arguing that the prosecuted manager was an insured under the same policy. The Board found that the exclusion for a prosecuted insured did not extend to the company, which had not been charged, and recommended that A Oy get legal expenses cover for the damages claim.
The liability insurer usually pays the defence in two situations. The first is when the claim concerns damage the policy covers. The second is when the insurer finds that your company is not liable, but the claimant keeps pursuing the claim and your company needs a lawyer to defend itself. In other cases liability insurance does not pay lawyers’ fees.
The liability cover for court costs has strict conditions in every Finnish wording. You must report the summons to the insurer without delay. The insurer must be able to appoint or approve the lawyer or take over the case. Most wordings require the report before your reply to the court is filed. A lawyer hired before the liability insurer was told is the most common way to lose this cover.
Professional mistakes are a third case. A consultant or designer whose advice causes a pure financial loss needs professional indemnity insurance, which also pays the defence costs of a covered claim. Legal expenses insurance is not a substitute for it.
When a dispute counts as having arisen
A dispute arises under Finnish legal expenses insurance when a claim that states its basis and amount has been denied. A disagreement, a demand letter or the other side’s silence is not yet a dispute. Costs incurred before the denial are not covered.
The wordings describe the denial in slightly different terms, for example as an express denial or as a denial that can be proved, but they lead to the same result. An undisputed debt is not an insured event, so collecting an invoice the customer has simply left unpaid is outside the cover.
Silence is the situation that most often moves the start of the cover. A company sends a claim, the other side does not answer, and the company hires a lawyer to prepare a lawsuit. Until the other side denies the claim, there is usually no dispute in the meaning of the policy. The lawyer’s fees for that period stay with the company. The rule is not without exceptions, though. If the claim was specific and the other side has stayed silent for a long time, a refusal based on the silence is worth having checked.
Three steps help:
- make the claim in writing and state its basis and amount
- ask the other side for its written position by a set date
- send the denial to your insurer together with your request for legal expenses cover
A refusal from an insurer counts as a denial too. When your insurer refuses a claim in writing, the dispute about that claim has arisen on the date of the refusal.
The two-year rule for new policies
If your legal expenses policy has been in force for less than two years when the dispute arises, the facts behind the dispute must also have arisen while the policy was in force. A new policy therefore does not cover a dispute over a contract signed before the policy started.
The rule is in all six Finnish wordings in almost the same words. Its purpose is to stop a company from buying cover when a dispute is already in sight. In a contract dispute the date that counts is usually the date the contract was made, not the date of the delivery or the denial.
A seller sold a compressor to X Oy in April 2012, took out legal expenses insurance in September and delivered the compressor in November. X Oy denied the price claim in July 2013. Cover was claimed under the seller’s own legal expenses insurance. The dispute was whether the claim was based on the sale or on the delivery.
Changing insurers does not restart the clock. The time under earlier consecutive legal expenses policies with similar cover counts towards the two years, also when they were with another insurer, unless the schedule limits this. A gap in the cover does restart it, so when you move the policy, make sure the new one starts the day the old one ends.
The same rule applies when you improve the cover during the contract. A higher limit or cover for the other side’s costs that has been in force for less than two years applies only to disputes whose basis arose after the change. Raising the limit when a dispute is already looming usually does not increase the compensation for that dispute. Fennia’s wording, for example, has no such rule for changes.
What business legal insurance does not cover
Business legal insurance does not cover general legal advice, disputes that belong to other policies or courts, or a list of excluded case types that is almost the same in all Finnish wordings.
The exclusion that surprises companies most is general legal advice, because legal expenses insurance is not a legal advice service. Drafting contracts, preparing a dismissal or negotiating with an employee are not cases that could go to court as such, so the insurers do not pay for them.
A Oy wanted to change an employee’s night shift duties and prepared a dismissal and a lay-off when the employee objected. An agreement was reached. Cover for the lawyer’s costs was claimed from A Oy’s own legal expenses insurance. The dispute was whether the matter could have gone straight to court.
One wording, If’s legal expenses insurance for construction services, includes up to 15 hours of preventive legal advice per policy period on contracts, employment, company law and the lease of the company’s own premises, but only before a dispute has arisen.
Some wordings, Fennia’s and Pohjantähti’s for example, tie the minor importance rule to the minimum deductible, so a claim around the minimum deductible or smaller can be excluded. In the others the insurer usually judges what is minor without a fixed euro limit. Lease disputes are also limited in some wordings, for example to a lease of the company’s own business premises.
Policy limit, deductible and the other side’s legal costs
The limit of indemnity and the deductible of a business legal expenses policy are written in the policy schedule, not in the wording. In the policies we see, the limit is often 25,000 to 30,000 euros, with a deductible of 15 percent of the costs and at least about 600 euros.
Companies often negotiate the minimum deductible up to 1,000 or 2,000 euros to lower the premium. Small disputes then fall entirely on the company. A limit of 10,000 euros can run out already in the district court, before an appeal.
The deductible is taken off the lawyer’s bill, not off the limit. The difference shows only when the bill is larger than the limit. In those cases we often see insurers take the deductible off the limit instead.
The figures are an example. In the right-hand column the bill less the deductible would be 30,600 euros, but the limit caps the payment at 30,000 euros.
If the compensation paid is exactly the limit minus the deductible, the decision probably contains this error.
The other side’s costs are the largest risk in a lost case. In Finland the losing party usually pays the winner’s legal costs. They are often about as large as your own. As a rule, the wordings pay the other side’s costs only if the cover has been added to the policy and written in the schedule. Pohjantähti’s wording, for example, also pays them without an extension in two narrow cases. Pohjola’s wording caps them at half the limit. Costs you agree to pay the other side in a settlement are not covered in any wording, even with the extension.
In our experience the most common gap in a company’s legal expenses cover is the missing extension for the other side’s costs, because the usual policy pays only the company’s own lawyer. If the company loses in court, the share it pays itself can easily reach tens of thousands of euros, even though the insurer paid the company’s own lawyer.
The insurer pays only reasonable fees. Reasonableness is judged by the value of the dispute, how difficult and extensive the case is, and the amount and quality of the work, as courts do when they order costs. There is no euro cap on the hourly rate, but the compensation is never more than the costs you claimed from the other side, so always claim your costs in full.
In FINE-038199 a limited partnership’s lawyer billed 61.7 hours and 17,276 euros for a simple debt dispute that ended in a settlement. The insurer paid for ten hours. FINE found that ten hours was normally enough for such a simple debt claim. A settlement does not need the insurer’s prior approval, but you cannot agree on the lawyer’s fees in a way that binds the insurer.
The insurer can cut the fee in two ways. If the hourly rate is too high, it pays only a reasonable rate. If the lawyer has used more hours than the case reasonably needed, it can cut the hours. Whether a cut is worth challenging depends on the case. Legal expenses insurance does not pay for a dispute with the insurer about how much the legal expenses insurance should pay, so a lawyer for that challenge can easily cost more than the extra compensation. The larger the amount, the more it pays to consider a lawyer who knows insurance matters and works for a fixed fee.
Your lawyer must be an advocate or another lawyer with a master’s degree in law. Otherwise the insurer pays nothing. Most insurers pay only when the case has been decided or settled, so the company pays the lawyer’s invoices in the meantime unless it agrees otherwise with the lawyer. Fennia pays a reasonable advance on the fees as a rule.
Commercial legal protection insurance from six Finnish insurers
Commercial legal protection insurance is another name for the same cover. The six Finnish wordings share the denial rule, the two-year rule and most exclusions but differ in the annual limit, the other side’s costs and a few case types.
Where the wordings differ
All six pay reasonable lawyer and court costs after a denied claim, apply the two-year rule and as a rule exclude costs that liability insurance pays.
Two differences change the outcome most often. In some wordings one limit covers all disputes in a policy period, so a second dispute in the same year gets nothing if the first one used up the limit. In Pohjola’s wording, for example, costs incurred before the main hearing and costs in a case resolved without a trial are capped at half the limit, which can make an early settlement more expensive for the company.
Your policy schedule can change the limit, the deductible, the territory and the extensions, so the schedule is the document to read first. An independent insurance broker in Finland can tell whether another insurer would give your business a higher limit or cover for the other side’s costs.
The costliest mistake – hiring a lawyer too early
The most expensive mistake we see is a company that hires a lawyer as soon as a damages claim arrives and then finds that neither its liability insurance nor its legal expenses insurance pays the bill.
The sequence is usually the same. A customer claims damages. The company reports the claim to its liability insurer and hires a lawyer at the same time. When the insurer finds that the company is not liable, the claimant drops the matter.
The company is not liable, but the lawyer’s bill remains. The liability insurance did not pay the lawyer, because the company never needed a defence against a continuing claim and the insurer was not given the chance to appoint the lawyer. The company then turns to its legal expenses insurance and is refused there too, because the work was done before any dispute had arisen. Costs of looking into a matter before a dispute are excluded in the wordings. A couple of them, LähiTapiola’s for example, pay for such work only if it is later used as evidence in the case.
The lawyer’s fees are not lost because legal expenses insurance comes second to liability insurance. They are lost because they arose too early for both policies. Legal expenses cover can apply from the moment the claim is denied and the case could go to court, but costs already incurred are not paid afterwards.
The way to avoid this is to let the insurers act first:
- Report a damages claim to your liability insurer before you hire anyone, and let it decide on the lawyer.
- Report a dispute to your legal expenses insurer in writing before the lawyer’s costs start. The claim for compensation must be made within one year of learning about the dispute and its consequences.
- Keep the claim and the denial as documents, because they show when the dispute arose.
A late report does not automatically mean that you lose the compensation. What matters is when the costs arose compared with the dispute.
Is company legal insurance worth it for a small business?
Company legal insurance is worth it for most small businesses that sign contracts with customers, suppliers or employees, because a single dispute in the district court can cost more in lawyers’ fees than many years of premiums.
Finnish insurers offer legal expenses insurance almost automatically as part of a business insurance package. Companies take it out together with their other usual voluntary policies, such as property and liability insurance. In the packages we see, it is often inexpensive and pays lawyers’ fees in many different kinds of disputes.
The annual premium starts from a few hundred euros and rises with the size of the company and its claims history. Even a small business can face a high premium if it has reported many disputes to its legal expenses insurance.
The two-year rule decides when to buy it. A policy bought after a contract has been signed does not cover disputes over that contract for the first two years. A new business should therefore take out legal expenses insurance before it signs its first important contracts, not when the first disagreement appears.
Three questions help to size the cover:
- How large are your typical contracts and invoices? A dispute about a 3,000 euro invoice may fall below a high minimum deductible.
- Could your company afford to pay the other side’s costs after a lost case? If not, ask for the extension.
- Do you have customers or suppliers outside Finland? Then check that the territory in the schedule is at least Europe.
Legal expenses insurance also matters if your company ever needs to challenge its own insurer. When a property, business interruption or liability claim is refused, the legal expenses cover usually pays most of the lawyer’s fee for challenging the decision.
Questions about business legal insurance in Finland
No. Professional indemnity insurance pays compensation and defence costs when a client claims that your professional mistake caused a financial loss. Commercial legal protection insurance pays your own lawyer in disputes where your company makes a claim or defends itself, but it excludes costs that a liability or professional indemnity policy pays.
Usually not. The legal expenses cover in a Finnish home insurance policy is meant for private life. Fennia’s home insurance wording, for example, excludes disputes connected with a profession, business or other income-earning activity. A sole trader needs business legal expenses insurance for disputes about the business.
Yes, as long as the lawyer is an advocate or has a master’s degree in law. Under liability insurance the insurer has the right to appoint or approve the lawyer, so ask it before you hire anyone.
Yes. A refused insurance claim is a denied claim, so the legal expenses insurance can pay the lawyer for challenging the decision in the Insurance Complaints Board or in court. The exception is a dispute about whether the legal expenses insurance itself pays.
No. Tax disputes are heard in the administrative courts. The Finnish wordings cover only cases that could go to a district court or arbitration.
Report it in writing before the lawyer’s costs start, and claim compensation within one year of learning about the dispute and its consequences. The Insurance Complaints Board has in some cases held that the year can start only when the lawyer was instructed, if the lawyer was hired clearly after the dispute arose.
No. Finnish insurers do not sell after-the-event cover for a single court case. The legal expenses insurance must be in force before the dispute arises. A new policy also usually falls under the two-year rule for disputes whose cause dates from before the policy began.
Has your insurer refused legal expenses cover?
Tell us what the dispute is about, when the other side denied your claim and what the insurer has said. We will check whether the refusal holds under your wording, whether the fee cut is reasonable and which of your policies should pay. If the refusal does not hold, we take it to the Insurance Complaints Board or to court.
Our fees: a single tender from 4,000 euros, ongoing broking from 5,000 euros a year. The fee is fixed and never a share of the premium. What the fee includes